Taylor Swift fans are on high alert after the Kansas City Chiefs owner’s wife, Tavia Hunt, gifted her a mysterious package during Swift’s latest game appearance. This unexpected gesture has set social media ablaze, with fans desperately piecing together clues from Hunt’s Instagram post. All that was revealed? A striking red box, adorned with the Chiefs’ logo and Kelce’s iconic number 87, wrapped in silver and yellow. Naturally, Swifties are convinced it’s something symbolic — maybe a piece of Chiefs gear customized just for her? Or, as some insiders are speculating, it could be something entirely out-of-the-box, possibly even a keepsake linked to Travis Kelce’s football achievements or Chiefs’ memorabilia exclusive to Swift.

For now, both Swift and Kelce are staying mum about what’s inside the box, driving fans wild with theories. Some are guessing it might be a lucky charm or a memento to solidify Swift’s “good luck” status for the Chiefs, who have thrived whenever she’s in the stands.

Taylor Swift fans were thrilled to see her back in Kansas City, showing up with her mom, Andrea, and brother, Austin, for the Chiefs’ Monday night game against the Buccaneers. Just days after wrapping her U.S. Eras Tour, the pop sensation made a stylish entrance at Arrowhead Stadium, sporting chic knee-high boots, black shorts, and a Chiefs bomber jacket. Fans couldn’t get enough of her and her family’s matching Chiefs gear, with Andrea looking just as game-ready as her superstar daughter. She rocked a Kansas City Chiefs and Eras tour inspired outfit: a black jacket that had the phrase “In My Chiefs Era” embroidered in red text.

Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce Hold Hands After Chiefs’ Season-Opener Win: See the Photos!

The couple were photographed walking hand-in-hand following the game at Arrowhead Stadium on Thursday, Sept. 5

Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce are stepping out!

On Thursday, Sept. 5, the couple were photographed holding hands as they left Arrowhead Stadium in Missouri following the Kansas City Chiefs win over the Baltimore Ravens.

Swift’s game day outfit consisted of a corseted denim Versace crop top, relaxed jean shorts and red thigh-high Giuseppe Zanotti boots, while Kelce, 34, changed into a matching white and orange gradient shirt and pants, which he teamed with a white vest, dark shades and cap.

Kansas City Chiefs tight end Travis Kelce, right, and Taylor Swift hold hands following an NFL football game between the Chiefs and the Baltimore Ravens

Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce hold hands at Arrowhead Stadium.AP Photo/Ed Zurga

Swift, 34, cheered on her man at the nail-biting game, which the Chiefs won 27-20 after Kelce spent much of the summer supporting her on her Eras Tour across Europe.

The pop superstar was seen watching the game with Travis’ dad Ed Kelce. The two were spotted seated next to each other in a box as they took in Travis’ NFL season debut and seen laughing together during NBC’s broadcast as Travis warmed up on the field below.

 Taylor Swift arrives ahead of the Kansas City Chiefs v Baltimore Ravens game

Taylor Swift arrives at Arrowhead Stadium.David Eulitt/Getty

They were also snapped standing and watching the field below, as Ed smiled and Swift gave a thumbs-up to nearby fans.

Ahead of the game, the musician arrived on a golf cart and greeted fans as she made her way into the stadium. “Hello… how are you guys?” Swift said as she walked through the stadium carrying a black Louis Vuitton purse in a video posted to X (formerly known as Twitter).

Earlier that day, Kansas City Chiefs CEO Clark Hunt told Today that while Swift’s game day appearances are “always a little bit of a surprise,” the “TV cameras will find her.”

Taylor Swift looks on from the upper level during an NFL football game between the Baltimore Ravens and the Kansas City Chiefs

Taylor Swift watches the game at Arrowhead Stadium.

Cooper Neill/Getty

Her appearance came one day after a representative for Travis told PEOPLE that documents that surfaced online titled “Comprehensive Media Plan for Travis Kelce’s Relations Following Breakup with Taylor Swift,” are “entirely false and fabricated.”

“These… were not created, issued or authorized by this agency,” Full Scope, the company that runs Travis’ PR, said in a statement.

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE’s free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer​​, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories. 

Travis Kelce #87 of the Kansas City Chiefs stretches prior to an NFL football game against the Baltimore Ravens

Travis Kelce ahead of the Kansas City Chiefs and Baltimore Ravens game.Kevin Sabitus/Getty

The Reddit thread that contained the documents has been deleted and the NFL tight end’s PR team told PEOPLE they are working with the online platform’s legal team “to initiate proceedings against the individuals or entities responsible for the unlawful and injurious forgery of documents.”

Swift attended her first Chiefs game nearly a year ago on Sept. 24, 2023. She and Travis then confirmed their romance the following month when they stepped out holding hands at a Saturday Night Live afterparty.