German Female POWs Saw Their First Black American Soldier in the Camp — Their Reaction Was

1) Arrival in Arizona: Propaganda Meets Reality

Arizona, September 1944. The transport truck carrying fourteen German women prisoners rolled through the gates of Camp Florence. Through dust-clouded windows, they glimpsed something propaganda had told them was impossible: American soldiers with dark skin, standing guard with the same uniforms and authority as any others.

.

.

.

The women fell silent. They had been taught these soldiers were inferior, dangerous, separate. Staff Sergeant Robert Williams stepped forward to conduct intake processing. His expression was professional, his voice firm. When he spoke in perfect German, the silence deepened. Everything they’d been taught was about to crack open.

Erica Hoffman, 25, had grown up in Düsseldorf, attending schools where racial hierarchy was taught as scientific fact. Greta Müller, 31, had been a teacher herself before joining the Luftwaffe auxiliary, perpetuating the curriculum she’d never questioned. Anna Weber, 19, had never met anyone different from herself; her small Bavarian town was homogeneous and insular. All fourteen shared similar backgrounds—middle-class Germans educated in a system that weaponized education and taught that America was mongrelized and weak because of its diversity.

They’d been told specifically about American soldiers of African descent—that they were unreliable, cowardly, inferior. The propaganda was systematic and pervasive, designed to dehumanize and create fear.

2) The Cracks Begin to Show

Their voyage from Casablanca to Norfolk took three weeks. The women, held below deck, processed defeat and uncertainty. During the crossing, they talked about their fears and what propaganda had taught them. Some questioned the logic: If the American military was so dysfunctional, how had they defeated the Afrika Korps? Answers were unsatisfying, but alternatives were more frightening.

They docked at Norfolk in late August. Processing took a week, all conducted by white American soldiers. The women felt relief and confusion. Where were the soldiers propaganda had warned about? Maybe they were kept separate. Maybe they wouldn’t encounter them.

On September 3rd, they boarded a train heading west, traveling through landscapes that stunned them: cities intact, farms abundant, towns showing no signs of war. America felt different from what they’d expected—more organized, more professional, less chaotic.

When they arrived at Camp Florence, the desert heat hit them like a wall. The guards waiting included men with dark skin, wearing the same uniforms, carrying the same authority. The women froze.

Staff Sergeant Williams, 32, from Alabama, educated at Tuskegee Institute and fluent in German, was assigned to Camp Florence for his language skills. He stepped forward, clipboard in hand, expression professional.

“I am Staff Sergeant Williams,” he said in flawless German. “I will be conducting your intake processing. Form a single line. Have your documentation ready.”

The women stood frozen, not from disobedience, but from cognitive dissonance. Everything was wrong. He spoke German perfectly. His bearing was military, confident, authoritative. He looked nothing like the propaganda cartoons, nothing like the caricatures they’d been shown.

Erica found her voice first. “You speak German?”

“Yes,” Williams replied. “I studied at Tuskegee Institute. My professor was Dr. Friedrich Brown, who taught in Berlin before immigrating.”

Erica had heard of him—a renowned linguist who’d left Germany when the regime came to power. The fact that this American soldier had studied under him was not impossible, but definitely not what propaganda had suggested.

Williams waited patiently while the women processed this information. He’d learned to give them time. The propaganda they’d absorbed took time to crack.

3) Routine and Unlearning

Slowly, the women formed a line. Williams began processing, checking documentation, recording information, assigning barracks. His German was better than some of the prisoners’. His demeanor was calm, professional, showing none of the characteristics propaganda had claimed.

When he reached Greta Müller, he paused. “You were a teacher?”

“Yes,” Greta replied.

“What subjects?”

“Mathematics, geography, some history.” She couldn’t bring herself to specify the kind of history.

Williams nodded. “Your mathematical skills may be useful. We need help with camp administration, inventory management, bookkeeping. If you’re interested, the work is available.”

“Yes, thank you.”

The women were assigned to compound C, barracks 7—a wooden structure with screened windows, thin mattresses, a pot-bellied stove, and a shared bathroom. Better than military barracks in Germany had been toward the war’s end.

As routine established itself—roll call, meals, work assignments—the women’s confusion grew. Erica worked in the laundry under Corporal James Washington, 26, from Chicago. He was patient, clear with instructions, fair in his expectations, treating German prisoners with professional courtesy. Erica was initially terrified, then gradually confused, eventually comfortable. “You’re doing good work,” Washington told her. “Keep it up.”

The mess hall was where propaganda met reality most directly. Guards and prisoners ate in the same facility, separated by section but sharing the same space. The women saw soldiers of different backgrounds working together, talking together, functioning as a unit.

“They’re integrated,” Greta observed. “The military. It’s not divided like we were told.”

4) The Library and the Truth

Camp Florence had a small library. Greta went frequently, seeking information. She found books written by authors of various backgrounds, newspapers describing American society in ways propaganda had never mentioned, evidence of a complexity propaganda had flattened into hierarchies.

One evening, Staff Sergeant Williams found her reading a history book. “Interesting reading?” he asked in German.

“Confusing reading,” Greta replied. “Everything here contradicts what I was taught.”

Williams sat down. “May I ask what you were taught?”

Greta hesitated, admitting the propaganda felt like confessing to a crime. But Williams waited patiently.

“We were taught that America was weak because of diversity,” she said. “That soldiers like you were inferior, that integration would destroy military effectiveness, that people like you weren’t fully human.”

Williams nodded. “We know what the German government taught. We’ve interrogated enough prisoners to understand the indoctrination. The question is, do you still believe it?”

“No,” Greta said immediately. Then, “I don’t know what I believe anymore. Everything I observe contradicts what I was taught. But unlearning a lifetime of education is… difficult.”

Williams agreed. “But necessary. Keep reading. Keep observing. Keep questioning. That’s how you find truth.”

5) Healing and Humanity

October brought an outbreak of influenza. Erica fell ill, high fever and severe cough. She was taken to the camp infirmary where the duty medic was Corporal Marcus Johnson, 24, from Philadelphia, trained as a physician’s assistant. Erica was terrified—propaganda had told her that medical personnel like Johnson were incompetent, dangerous—but she was too sick to protest.

Johnson examined her professionally, administered medication, checked on her regularly, treated her with the same care he’d give anyone.

On the fourth day, when her fever broke, Erica said in careful English, “You saved my life.”

“I did my job,” Johnson replied. “Just like I would for anyone.”

“But I’m…”

“Human,” Johnson supplied. “Yes, you are. That’s all that matters here.”

Tears ran down Erica’s face. “We were taught you were incapable of skill, compassion, of being fully human. How could we believe such lies?”

Johnson sat on the edge of her cot. “Lies are easy to believe when they make you feel superior, when questioning them costs you safety. The important thing is that you’re questioning them now.”

6) Letters Home: Seeds of Change

In November, prisoners received authorization to send letters home through the Red Cross. Greta wrote to her sister, who was teaching in Munich:

“Dear Margaret, I am well and being treated fairly in the prisoner camp. I have learned many things here. Most importantly, I have learned that everything we were taught was lies. The propaganda about America, about diversity, about supposed hierarchies of human worth, all of it was false. I have met people here who prove through their competence, their kindness, their humanity that what we believed was propaganda designed to make us feel superior. When I return, I will teach truth. I will teach children that humans are equal in worth regardless of background. I will dismantle what I helped build. This is my penance and my duty. Your sister, Greta.”

Erica wrote to her parents:

“Dear mother and father, I am safe in America. The camp is decent. We have food and shelter and work. I have learned something important here. We were lied to about Americans, about so much. The people guarding us are kind, professional, human. Everything propaganda taught was false. When I come home, I will tell you truth. I hope you will listen. Your daughter Erica.”

Anna wrote to her boyfriend:

“Dearest Friedrich, if you survive this war and come home, we must talk about what we were taught, about propaganda, about lies we believed. I am learning in this camp that we were wrong about so much. When you return, be prepared to question everything. I am your Anna.”

The letters represented a beginning—a process where propaganda’s lies would be dismantled person by person, conversation by conversation, truth by truth.

7) Farewell and Legacy

December brought Christmas. The camp chaplain organized a service, prayers offered in multiple languages, a message about reconciliation and hope. After the service, Staff Sergeant Williams approached the group of German women.

“Merry Christmas,” he said in German. “May the new year bring you peace and wisdom.”

“Thank you, Sergeant,” Greta replied. “May I ask you something?”

“Of course.”

“How did you survive it? Serving in a military that didn’t always treat you fairly, dealing with prisoners who’d been taught to hate you. How did you keep your humanity?”

Williams smiled sadly. “By remembering that systems are bigger than individuals. By recognizing that you women didn’t create the propaganda, you were victims of it. By choosing to judge people by their actions rather than their indoctrination. By believing that education can overcome ignorance if given the chance.”

He handed her a book—a worn copy of Frederick Douglass’s autobiography. “Read this. When you return to Germany, share it with students. Let them learn from someone who understood that education is the path to freedom.”

Greta accepted the book with trembling hands. “Thank you for everything, for being patient with us, for teaching us truth, for not hating us despite what we believed.”

“I could never hate you,” Williams said quietly. “You’re just people who were lied to. Now you know better. Now you can do better.”

March 1946 brought repatriation orders. On their last evening, the fourteen women gathered in their barracks, reflecting on eight months that had transformed their understanding of the world.

“I can’t believe I was afraid of Sergeant Williams,” Anna said. “He’s the kindest person I’ve met in years.”

“I was terrified of Corporal Johnson,” Erica admitted. “Now I’m grateful he saved my life and taught me what real competence looks like.”

“I taught children lies,” Greta said heavily. “I perpetuated propaganda. That guilt will never leave me.”

“Then use it,” Helen suggested. “Use it to motivate you to teach truth now, to help dismantle what you helped build.”

The next morning, Williams supervised their departure. As Greta passed, she held his hand longer than protocol allowed. “Thank you,” she said, “for teaching us, for being patient, for showing us what we couldn’t see before.”

“You’re welcome,” Williams replied. “Now go teach others. Be the change Germany needs.”

8) Aftermath: Truth as Reparation

Germany in March 1946 was rubble and hunger and occupation. The women dispersed to their home regions, found destroyed cities and devastated families, but also opportunities—teaching positions in schools desperate for educators, administrative jobs in reconstruction offices, work helping process refugees.

Greta returned to teaching. Her first lesson was about propaganda—how to recognize it, how to resist it, how to question sources. “I was taught lies,” she told her students. “I believed them because I wasn’t taught to question. You will learn to question. You will learn to test claims against evidence. You will learn that humans are equal in worth regardless of background. This is truth. Everything else is propaganda.”

Erica became a translator for occupation forces, working to bridge language barriers between Germans and Americans. Anna opened a café, hiring workers of different backgrounds, building bridges across divides propaganda had created.

Each woman carried forward the lessons learned in Camp Florence. Greta wrote to Williams in 1947, thanking him for teaching her persistence in truth matters more than comfort in lies. Williams replied, “Teaching truth is always difficult, but it is necessary. Keep teaching. Keep questioning. That is how we build a better world, one student, one truth, one generation at a time.”

They corresponded for years, Williams sending books, Greta sharing them with students, building a library of truth to counter propaganda.

In 1984, seven of the original group organized a reunion in Munich. They remembered their fear, their shame, and how they learned, questioned, and changed. They located Williams in Atlanta, where he’d retired after thirty years in the army, and wrote to thank him for his patience and teaching.

Williams replied, “I am proud of what you did afterward. Proud that you taught truth. Proud that you turned shame into action. This is how wars truly end. Not with treaties, but with individuals choosing to be better.”

Williams died in 1996. Greta traveled to Atlanta for his funeral, the only one of the original group still alive. At his grave, she placed a copy of Frederick Douglass’s autobiography—the same book he’d given her. Inside, she wrote, “You freed me from the prison of propaganda. I hope I helped free others. Thank you eternally.”

9) The Real Victory

The story of Camp Florence is small in the grand narrative of World War II. No major battle turned on what happened there. No strategic objective was accomplished by Staff Sergeant Williams teaching German prisoners to question propaganda. But for fourteen women who arrived terrified and left transformed, it was everything.

For the students they taught afterward, for Germany’s reconstruction, for the slow defeat of lies by truth, it was essential.

This is how wars truly end. Not with surrender documents or tribunals, but with individuals encountering truth that contradicts propaganda, with teachers teaching truth instead of lies, with people choosing to be better than their indoctrination.

Staff Sergeant Robert Williams taught German prisoners that humans are equal, that capability transcends background, that propaganda is always designed to divide us, and that education is the path to freedom.

They learned. They taught others. The lesson propagated forward, generation after generation—truth defeating lies one mind at a time.

That is the legacy. Not victory or defeat. Not politics or policy, but one man with patience and fourteen women with courage to question what they’d been taught. Just truth defeating propaganda, one conversation at a time. Just humanity recognized across every artificial divide. Just the simple lesson that we are all finally, and fundamentally, human beings deserving of dignity and respect.

That lesson learned in a prisoner camp in Arizona in 1944 echoes forward still—a reminder that education can overcome indoctrination, that truth can defeat lies, and that individuals can choose to be better than their propaganda.

One person at a time. One truth at a time. One brave question at a time. That’s how we prevent the next war. That’s how we build peace. That’s how we remain human.