Julian Edelman Blasts Madden Ratings: “How Is Mahomes Not a 99?” — While Gronk Defends Lane Johnson’s Spot

Few annual debates in the NFL world ignite as much passion as the release of Madden’s player ratings. This year, the biggest shock came with the exclusion of Kansas City Chiefs quarterback Patrick Mahomes from the coveted 99 Club—a status he has held for the past four editions of the game. The decision has drawn sharp criticism from fans and former players alike, with many questioning how the league’s most consistent superstar could be left out.

Mahomes’ Omission Sparks Outrage

Since stepping in as the Chiefs’ starting quarterback, Mahomes has been a model of excellence, leading Kansas City to the AFC Championship Game every year and delivering highlight-reel performances despite adversity. Madden had previously recognized his brilliance with a perfect 99 overall rating, but his streak ended this year, and the reaction was immediate.

Former New England Patriots star Julian Edelman was among the most vocal critics. He pointed to Mahomes’ ability to carry an injury-riddled offense—one plagued by injuries to receivers and a battered offensive line—yet still lead the team to 15 wins and another Super Bowl appearance.

“How is Patrick Mahomes not a 99? He literally had a depleted team last year. All of his receivers were hurt. His offensive line got shattered. They had two losses last year. They go to the Super Bowl for a threepeat. This guy is not a 99. I think that’s crazy. He is still the best player in football. Josh Allen and Lamar still haven’t beaten him when it mattered. He didn’t even have the teams,” Edelman argued.

Who Made the 99 Club?

If not Mahomes, then who did make the cut? The 99 Club for Madden 26 features some of the NFL’s brightest stars:

– Saquon Barkley : The reigning NFL Offensive Player of the Year and Madden 26 cover athlete.
– Lane Johnson : The Philadelphia Eagles’ right tackle, a two-time Super Bowl champion, finally recognized with a 99 rating.
– Josh Allen : The reigning MVP, reclaiming his place among the elite.
– Lamar Jackson : Two-time MVP and three-time First-Team All-Pro.
– Ja’Marr Chase and Justin Jefferson : Both wide receivers coming off standout seasons.
– Myles Garrett : The Browns’ defensive force, continuing his dominant play.

Gronkowski Defends Lane Johnson’s Inclusion

While Mahomes’ absence raised eyebrows, another inclusion drew praise—especially from former Patriots tight end Rob Gronkowski. Gronkowski was thrilled to see Lane Johnson, an offensive lineman, finally earn a spot in the 99 Club, calling it long overdue.

“Most surprising is Lane Johnson, just because he is an offensive lineman, but he deserves it. He has like a torn meniscus, quad, whatever it is, and goes through it. He doesn’t even deal with pain. He just fights through anything and just takes it out on his opponent,” Gronkowski said.

Gronkowski’s endorsement highlights the often-overlooked contributions of offensive linemen, who rarely receive such high-profile recognition in video game ratings or media coverage.

Is Mahomes Still the Best?

Despite Mahomes’ continued success, questions about his individual dominance have surfaced. Some analysts argue that the Chiefs’ recent achievements have been driven more by their elite defense than by Mahomes’ heroics. When the defense faltered in the Super Bowl, Mahomes struggled, and the team’s vulnerabilities were exposed.

Critics suggest that while Mahomes’ past accolades are impressive, the 99 Club should reflect current performance rather than legacy or reputation. By that metric, they argue, Mahomes simply wasn’t at the same level last season.

The Verdict

The debate over Mahomes’ rating is likely to continue throughout the season, with passionate arguments on both sides. For now, Madden’s 99 Club is reserved for those considered the very best in the game at this moment—not just those with the most impressive resumes. Whether Mahomes reclaims his spot next year may depend on how he and the Chiefs respond to the challenges ahead.