Paper slaps the table. A chair scrapes hard on concrete. Somewhere down the corridor, a phone rings and no one moves to answer it. A hand tightens around a pencil until the wood caks. Eyes flick to the doorway, then away. Not fear of the enemy. Fear of what’s standing three steps behind the furer’s chair.
A woman’s laugh, soft, almost bored, floats in from the next room like smoke. One officer swallows. Another stares at the map, pretending not to hear. A signature waits at the bottom of a page. The ink hovers. A sleeve trembles. Because in this bunker, one wrong word doesn’t ruin your career. It ruins your life.
And tonight, the generals aren’t arguing about armies. They’re arguing about her. This is a story rarely told. Not the battles, not the campaigns, not the grand strategy of World War II. This is the story of the woman who stood in the shadows of the Third Reich. Invisible to the German public, unknown to most of the world, yet somehow present at the very center of power.
Ava Brown. The generals despised her. They feared her. They whispered about her in corridors and cursed her name in private. And until now, you’ve probably never understood why. To understand their hatred, we must first understand a simple truth. Adolf Hitler was not just a military commander.
He was not merely a political leader. By 1939, he had become something far more dangerous. He had become a living myth, a figure worshiped by millions, a man whose word was law and whose approval meant everything. And in that world where grown men trembled at his frown, and field marshals competed for a nod of recognition, one person had something none of them could ever possess.
Ava Brawn had his affection. She had his trust. She had access to his private moments when the uniform came off and the mask slipped. And that made her the most dangerous woman in Germany. The generals who ran Hitler’s war machine were men of discipline and tradition. They had risen through the rigid hierarchy of the German military, where rank meant everything, and protocol governed every interaction.
They understood power as something earned through service, demonstrated through competence, wielded through formal channels. And then there was Eva. She had no rank. She held no position. She appeared on no organizational chart. She existed in a space they could not enter, could not influence, could not even acknowledge publicly.
She was the ghost at the edge of every photograph. The presence that could shift Hitler’s mood in an instant. The woman whose whispered word might carry more weight than a carefully prepared briefing. But here’s what makes this story truly remarkable. Ava Brown was not a schemer. She was not a political operator.
By most accounts, she was a simple woman with simple desires, someone who wanted love and attention and a normal life with the man she adored. And that made her even more threatening to the generals because they knew how to fight against ambition. They knew how to counter political maneuvering. What they could not fight was genuine intimacy.
What they could not counter was the fact that when the doors closed and the maps were rolled away, Hitler turned to her and not to them. Let’s go back to the beginning. It was 1929 and Ava Brown was 17 years old. She worked as an assistant in a photography studio in Munich, owned by Hinrich Hoffman, Hitler’s personal photographer.
She was blonde, athletic, and unremarkable in almost every way. She came from a middle-class Catholic family. Her father was a school teacher. She had no particular political convictions, no grand ambitions, no special talents. She liked fashion, movies, and sports. She was by all measures an ordinary young woman in an extraordinary time.
Hitler first noticed her in Hoffman’s studio. He was already a rising political figure, leader of the National Socialist German Workers Party, a man on the verge of reshaping German history. What drew him to this teenage shop assistant remains unclear. Perhaps it was her youth and energy. Perhaps it was her very ordinariness, a contrast to the intensity of his political world.
Perhaps he simply liked the way she looked at him without the fear or calculation he saw in everyone else’s eyes. Whatever the reason, he began to pursue her. But here’s the first twist in our story. Hitler did not want a wife. He had a carefully constructed public image as a man married to Germany, devoted entirely to his nation with no room in his heart for personal attachments.
A visible relationship would shatter that image. So from the very beginning, Ava Bran was condemned to secrecy. She would be hidden, denied, kept in the shadows. And she accepted it. She accepted all of it because she was in love. The early years were brutal for Ava. Hitler would appear, shower her with attention, then vanish for weeks or months at a time.
He gave her gifts, but never commitment. He offered moments of tenderness followed by long silences.She was not permitted to attend public functions. She was not introduced to important visitors. When Hitler traveled, she stayed behind. When he appeared in photographs, she was cropped out. She existed in a strange limbo, neither girlfriend nor wife, neither public nor entirely private, and it began to destroy her.
In August 1932, Ava Brown attempted suicide for the first time. She shot herself in the neck with her father’s pistol. The wound was not fatal. Hitler rushed to her bedside, suddenly attentive, suddenly devoted. And then, within weeks, he slipped back into his old patterns. 17 months later in May 1935, she tried again.
This time she took an overdose of sleeping pills. Again she survived. Again Hitler appeared concerned and apologetic. And this time something changed. After the second suicide attempt, Hitler made Ava Braun his official mistress, though still in secret from the German public. He installed her at the Burgof, his mountain retreat in the Bavarian Alps.
He gave her an allowance. He bought her a house in Munich. He granted her a status that while invisible to the outside world was very real within the inner circle. And this is when the general’s troubles truly began. The Burgof was not just a vacation home. It was the alternate seat of power in Nazi Germany.
Hitler spent enormous amounts of time there, especially as the war progressed and Berlin became increasingly dangerous. Important meetings happened at the Burgof. Crucial decisions were made. Foreign dignitaries visited and Ava Brown was there presiding over it all like an unofficial queen. Now imagine you are a general in the German army.
You have spent your entire career earning your position. You have commanded troops, studied tactics, proven yourself in the most demanding profession in the world, and now you must travel to a mountain retreat to brief the furer on matters of life and death, only to find yourself in what feels like a resort hotel with a hostess who asks about your trip and offers you tea.
The contrast was jarring, the atmosphere was surreal, and it was absolutely intentional. Hitler used the Burgov to keep his inner circle off balance. The informal setting stripped away the military hierarchy that gave generals their power. In Berlin, they were commanders. At the Burgof, they were guests, and guests are expected to be polite, to follow the rules of the house to defer to the hostess.
Ava Brown understood this perfectly, even if she never articulated it in political terms. She set the social tone. She decided who was comfortable and who was not. She noticed who was polite and who was dismissive. And Hitler noticed what she noticed. Here’s something most people don’t realize about Ava Brown.
She kept detailed diaries and had a remarkable memory for personal interactions. If a general was rude to her, if someone looked at her with contempt, if anyone treated her as less than the lady of the house, she remembered. And while she rarely complained directly to Hitler, the information had a way of surfacing. a comment at dinner, a casual observation, a subtle question about why a certain person seemed so uncomfortable in her presence.
Hitler was fiercely protective of her. An insult to Ava was an insult to him, and insulting Hitler was not a survivable mistake. The generals found themselves in an impossible position. They could not acknowledge her publicly because Hitler insisted on maintaining his image as a man married to Germany. They could not ignore her privately because she was always there, always watching, always present at the edges of power.
They could not treat her as an equal because she had no official status. They could not treat her as a servant because she clearly was not. She existed in a category that their rigid minds could not process, and that uncertainty bred resentment. But there was something deeper than mere protocol frustrating the generals.
Ava Brown represented a fundamental truth they did not want to accept. Hitler was not a military genius making purely rational decisions based on strategic calculation. Hitler was a human being with emotions, attachments, and personal needs. He was a man who wanted to be loved, who craved domestic comfort, who sometimes preferred tea with his girlfriend to conferences with his commanders, and that terrified them.
Because if Hitler was human, then his decisions might be influenced by human factors. If Hitler was fallible, then they might be following a fallible man into catastrophe. It was easier to hate Ever Brawn than to confront that possibility. Let’s look at specific incidents that crystallized this hatred. In the summer of 1942, the German army was deep in the Soviet Union, fighting the most brutal campaign in military history.
Hundreds of thousands of soldiers were dying on the Eastern Front. The generals were desperate for clear guidance, for resources, for decisions that could only come from Hitler himself. And where was Hitler? Hewas at the Burgof taking long walks with Ava, watching movies in the evening, discussing architecture with Albert Shar.
When urgent messages arrived from the front, they sometimes sat for hours before Hitler could be disturbed. General France Halder, chief of the army general staff, arrived at the Burghoff in August 1942 for a critical meeting. He found Hitler relaxed, informal, seemingly disconnected from the urgency of the situation. Ava Brown was present at dinner that evening, chatting about her plans to remodel one of the guest rooms.
Halda sat in barely concealed fury as the conversation drifted from upholstery to flower arrangements while army group south fought for its life near Stalingrad. Within weeks, Hitler dismissed Halder. The official reason was disagreements over strategy. But Haldder always believed that his visible contempt for the Burghoff atmosphere had played a role.
General Obur Hines Gderion had a different experience with the Ava Brown problem. Gudderion was one of Germany’s most brilliant tank commanders, a pioneer of armored warfare, a man whose tactical innovations had helped conquer France in 6 weeks. He was also blunt, outspoken, and entirely incapable of hiding his opinions.
When he visited the Burghoff, he made no effort to participate in the social rituals. He refused to make small talk with Ava. He visibly checked his watch during dinner. He treated the entire atmosphere as an irritating delay before the real business could begin. Ava noticed. She always noticed. And she began to make small comments to Hitler about Gderion’s rudeness, his impatience, his inability to relax and enjoy himself even for an evening.
Hitler, who was already frustrated with Gudderion’s tendency to argue with him in military conferences, began to see those arguments in a new light. Was Gudderion simply offering professional advice or was he fundamentally disrespectful? The question poisoned the relationship. In December 1941, Hitler dismissed Gudderion from command.
He would eventually recall him, but the relationship never recovered its former warmth. Field Marshall Wilhelm Kitle took the opposite approach. He decided to cultivate Ava Brown to treat her with elaborate courtesy to become a fixture at the Burghov social scene. Kitle was not a man of great military talent. His primary skill was his absolute loyalty to Hitler.
His willingness to agree with whatever the Furer decided. Other generals mocked him privately, calling him a lackey and a yes man. But Kitle understood something they didn’t. He understood that access was power and Ava Brown controlled Access. So Kitle smiled at her jokes. He complimented her dresses. He brought her small gifts and remembered the names of her dogs.
He became a familiar presence at the long dinners, never showing impatience, never checking his watch. And it worked. Hitler trusted Kitle more than almost anyone else, kept him close through the entire war, relied on him even as more competent generals were dismissed. Whether AA’s influence played a direct role is impossible to prove, but Kitel clearly believed it did, and he acted accordingly.
But here is where our story takes its darkest turn. It was not just access and atmosphere that made the generals hate Ava Brown. It was what she represented about Hitler’s decision-making in the final years of the war. By 1944, Germany was losing on every front. The Allies had landed in Normandy. The Soviet Union was pushing west.
The cities were being bombed into rubble. Any rational leader would have begun seeking a way out, looking for diplomatic solutions, considering how to minimize the final catastrophe. But Hitler was not a rational leader. Hitler was a man who had retreated into a private world surrounded by loyalists and sickants with Ava Brawn at the center of that world.
The generals who tried to argue for strategic retreats, for defensive positions, for any hint of realism found themselves facing a wall of denial. Hitler refused to accept that the war was lost. He clung to fantasies of miracle weapons and lastminute reversals. And part of that fantasy was the domestic world that Ava Brown maintained.
She kept the Bhoff running normally even as the Reich crumbled. She planned parties while cities burned. She discussed fashion while entire army groups were surrounded and destroyed. And Hitler seemed to prefer her reality to the one his generals were trying to show him. This was the deepest source of their hatred.
Eva Brown was not just a distraction from military business. She was a symbol of Hitler’s disconnection from reality, a living embodiment of the fantasy world he had constructed to avoid facing the consequences of his decisions. When they looked at her, they saw everything that was wrong with the leadership of the Third Reich.
They saw a man who preferred comfortable illusions to harsh truths, who surrounded himself with people who would not challenge him, who retreated intoprivate pleasures while demanding that millions die for his ambitions. But we should pause here and consider something uncomfortable. The generals who hated Ava Braun were not heroes.
They were not moral exemplars who deserved sympathy. These were men who had enabled Hitler’s rise, who had helped him wage aggressive war, who had at minimum tolerated and often actively participated in war crimes. Their hatred of Ava Brown was not principled opposition to a corrupt regime.
It was professional resentment mixed with personal jealousy. They hated her because she had influence they could not control, not because they disagreed with what Hitler was doing with that influence. This is the bitter truth at the heart of our story. The conflict between Hitler’s generals and Ava Brown was not a conflict between good and evil, between military professionalism and civilian interference, between rational strategy and emotional distraction.
It was a conflict within a fundamentally corrupt system, a struggle for influence among people who had all made their peace with atrocity. Ava Brown did not make Hitler worse. She did not corrupt a military leadership that might otherwise have restrained him. She was simply a convenient target for men who needed someone to blame for their own failures and compromises.
Let’s move to the final chapter. By January 1945, the Burghoff was no longer safe. Allied bombers could reach it now. The mountain retreat that had been the alternate seat of power became just another target. Hitler moved permanently to Berlin to the underground bunker complex beneath the Reich Chancellery and Ava Brown came with him. This was not expected.
Hitler had ordered her to stay in Munich to stay safe, to survive whatever was coming. She refused. For the first time in their relationship, she directly defied him. She would not be hidden away. She would not be protected. If he was going to die in Berlin, she would die with him. And so she came to the bunker to the cramped underground rooms where the final drama of the Third Reich would play out.
The atmosphere in the bunker was different from the Burgoff. There were no long dinners, no walks in the garden, no pretense of normal life. Everyone knew the end was coming. The Soviet army was fighting through the streets of Berlin. The sound of artillery was constant. The bunker shook with each explosion. And still Ava Brown was there, still the hostess, still trying to maintain some semblance of civilization in the heart of chaos.
The generals who remained were a diminished group. Most of the senior commanders had found reasons to be elsewhere. Those who were left were either trapped or genuinely loyal, and they found Ava Brawn impossible to avoid. She was present at the daily briefings, standing quietly at the edge of the room. She was there in the common areas, making conversation, offering coffee, asking about families and homes that would never be seen again.
She was everywhere, inescapable, a constant reminder of the surreal domesticity that Hitler insisted on maintaining. Even now, some of the remaining officers were surprised to find that they no longer hated her. General Our Hans Krebs, who had replaced Gderion as chief of the army general staff, found her presence oddly comforting.
She was calm when everyone else was panicking. She was kind when everyone else was snapping and snarling. She treated the bunker staff with courtesy, remembered their names, asked about their concerns. In the final days, she was perhaps the only person in the bunker who was not shouting at anyone. But others maintained their resentment to the end.
General Obururst Alfred Yodel, chief of operations for the armed forces, could barely stand to be in the same room with her. He saw her continued presence as the ultimate evidence of Hitler’s detachment from reality. While soldiers died by the thousands in hopeless lastditch defenses, Hitler was worrying about wedding arrangements.
Because that was what happened on April 29th, 1945, less than 40 hours before Hitler’s death. He married Ava Brown. The wedding was a small rushed affair. A minor city official was found and brought to the bunker to perform the ceremony. Gerbles and Borman served as witnesses. Ava wore a black dress because no white dress could be found.
She signed the marriage certificate, starting to write her maiden name before crossing it out and writing Ava Hitler instead. After years of secrecy, she was finally acknowledged. After years of being hidden, she was finally the Furer’s wife. For approximately 35 hours, the generals who learned of the wedding had various reactions.
Some were too exhausted to care. Some felt a grim satisfaction that at least one secret was finally in the open, [clears throat] but others saw it as the final insult. Hitler had spent years maintaining his image as a man devoted solely to Germany. He had sacrificed military advantage to protect that image. He had hidden Ava Brown, denied her, kept herin the shadows, all to preserve a fiction of selfless dedication.
And now in the final moments he had abandoned that fiction for a wedding certificate. It was as if everything they had worked for, everything they had sacrificed had been thrown away for a gesture of personal sentimentality. On April 30th, 1945, Adolf Hitler and Ava Hitler died together in the bunker. They took poison and Hitler also shot himself.
Their bodies were carried to the Chancellory Garden and burned. Ava Brawn, who had spent 16 years loving a man who could not love her back in any normal way, who had sacrificed her youth and her identity for a relationship she could never acknowledge, who had chosen death over survival was gone. And with her death, the hatred of the generals became moot.
But the story does not end there. In the decades after the war, as historians began to piece together the inner workings of the Third Reich, Ever Brown became a figure of fascination. Who was she really? What did she know about the crimes being committed in her partner’s name? How much influence did she actually have? And were the generals right to see her as a threat? The evidence suggests a complicated picture.
Everbrun was not a political figure. She did not attend strategy meetings or read secret documents. She had no interest in policy and no understanding of military affairs. When generals accused her of influencing Hitler’s decisions, they were largely projecting their own fears onto a woman who simply wanted to be loved.
But that does not mean she had no impact. Ava Braun shaped the atmosphere in which Hitler made decisions. She created the domestic bubble that allowed him to retreat from unpleasant realities. She enabled his fantasy of a normal life even as he directed the machinery of destruction. She was not an active participant in evil, but she was part of the structure that made evil possible.
She helped Hitler maintain the psychological compartmentalization that allowed him to order mass murder in the morning and discuss interior decoration in the afternoon. The generals understood this intuitively, even if they could not articulate it. They felt that something was deeply wrong with the way Hitler operated, with the atmosphere of the Burghoff, with the blurring of personal and professional spheres.
They blamed Eva Brown because she was visible and vulnerable, because she could be resented without risking Hitler’s wrath, because she represented everything that disturbed them about their leader. But the real problem was not Ava Braun. The real problem was Hitler. and by focusing their hatred on her.
The generals avoided confronting the true source of their predicament. This is the bitter truth that emerges from our story. The generals hated Ava Braun because hating her was safe. They could not hate Hitler upon whom their careers and lives depended. They could not hate themselves for the compromises they had made.
They could not hate the system that had elevated them to power. So they hated the woman who loved Hitler as if removing her would somehow fix everything that was broken. It didn’t work. Of course, Ava Bran was never the problem. She was a symptom of the problem, a manifestation of Hitler’s need to create a private world insulated from the consequences of his public actions.
Even if she had never existed, the fundamental dynamics would have been the same. Hitler would still have retreated from reality. He would still have surrounded himself with loyalists. He would still have refused to hear advice he did not want to hear. The generals would still have found themselves marginalized, ignored, blamed for failures not of their making.
But Ava Brown was there. She was present, visible, vulnerable. And so she became the focus of hatred that had nowhere else to go. She became the explanation for why things were not working, why the furer could not see the truth, why the military leadership could not make itself heard. She was not guilty of anything except loving the wrong man.
But in the world of the Third Reich, that was guilt enough. When we look back on this story, we see something that goes beyond the specific personalities involved. We see a pattern that repeats throughout history in many different contexts. When powerful men fail, they often look for someone to blame. When their advice is ignored, they often focus their resentment on whoever seems to have the ear of power.
Wives, mistresses, advisers, favorites, all become targets for frustration that cannot be directed at the actual decision maker. Ava Brown was not unique. She was just the most dramatic example of a phenomenon as old as power itself. The final image of our story is the burned remains in the Chancellor Garden.
Two bodies so badly damaged that they would never be definitively identified by physical examination alone. Everything that Hitler and Ava Brown had been, everything they had done, everything they had represented, reduced to ash and scattered by thewind. The generals who had hated her were also gone, dead or captured or fleeing across a ruined continent.
The world they had all inhabited the strange court of the Third Reich with its mixture of brutality and bourgeois pretention had vanished as completely as if it had never existed. But the questions remain. What drove a simple young woman to attach herself to one of history’s greatest monsters? What made powerful military commanders resent her so intensely? And what does their hatred tell us about the psychology of power? The dynamics of inner circles, the way that personal relationships shape political outcomes. Ava Braun did not
change history. She was not a turning point, a decision maker, a figure whose choices altered the course of events. But she was there at the center of everything, watching and being watched, loved by one man and hated by many others. Her presence reminds us that even the most catastrophic events in history happened in contexts that included personal relationships, domestic dramas, and the messy realities of human emotion.
The Third Reich was not just a political movement or a military machine. It was also a collection of human beings who loved and hated, who sought power and feared losing it, who constructed elaborate hierarchies and then struggled to navigate them. The generals hated Ava Braun because she reminded them of their own powerlessness.
They had rank and authority and the outward trappings of command. But in the end, they could not influence the one man who mattered. They could not reach him, could not persuade him, could not even get his full attention. And she could. She had something they would never have. She had access to the private Hitler, the man behind the image.
And in a system where everything depended on one person’s decisions, that access was the ultimate power. This is the bitter truth that our title promised. The hatred of the generals was not really about Ava Braun at all. It was about their own failure, their own compromise, their own inability to confront the real source of their problems.
She was just the easiest target, the most visible symptom of a disease they could not cure. And when she died with Hitler in the bunker, she took their excuse with her. After that, they could no longer blame the woman at the edge of the photographs. They could only blame themselves. And that perhaps was the most bitter truth of all.
The story of Hitler’s inner circle reminds us that history is made by human beings with all their flaws, jealousies, and miscalculations. The generals who planned campaigns and moved armies were also men who worried about their standing at court, who envied those with more access, who looked for someone to blame when things went wrong.
They were not chess pieces moving across a strategic board. They were people as complicated and contradictory as anyone else. And understanding that complexity is essential to understanding how history actually happens. Ava Brown has been largely forgotten by mainstream history. She appears in footnotes, in specialized studies, in the occasional documentary.
But in her time, in that claustrophobic world of the Third Reich, she was a figure of immense importance to the people around her. The generals thought about her constantly. They adjusted their behavior because of her. They calculated how their actions might be perceived by her. She shaped their experience of power even though she never held any official position.
Perhaps that is the final lesson of our story. Power is not just about titles and commands. It is about relationships, perceptions, and access. The generals had military power, but they lacked the power that mattered most in Hitler’s Germany. The power to influence the man at the top.
Ava Brown had no military power, no political power, no official status of any kind. But she had something the generals could never achieve. She had Hitler’s attention when the doors were closed. And in the strange world of the Third Reich, that was everything. The bunker is empty now. The building above it was demolished long ago.
The garden where the bodies burned has been paved over. Nothing remains of that world except documents and photographs and the memories of those who survived. But the dynamics that played out there continue to appear in different forms, in different contexts, wherever power concentrates in the hands of a few. The resentment of those who have formal authority but lack real influence.
The power of those who have access to the leader private moments. The search for scapegoats when things go wrong. These patterns repeat because they are rooted in human nature, not in any particular historical situation. Ava Brown did not deserve the hatred directed at her. She was not a villain, not a schemer, not a figure of historical significance in her own right.
She was a woman who made a terrible choice in her youth and then spent her life living with theconsequences of that choice. She loved a monster and called it love. She accepted secrecy and humiliation and called it devotion. She stayed until the end and called it loyalty. Whether that makes her a victim or a collaborator or something in between is a question without a clear answer.
But the generals who hated her were not in a position to judge. They had made their own terrible choices. They had enabled Hitler’s rise. They had executed his orders. They had looked away from crimes that should have been impossible to ignore. Their hatred of Ava Brown was not moral outrage at her association with evil.
It was professional resentment at her proximity to power. And that distinction matters. When we judge the past, we must be careful about who we cast as heroes and villains. The story of the Third Reich is not a story of good people fighting against bad people. It is a story of various degrees of complicity, various shades of gray, various forms of moral failure.
The generals who hated Ava Brown were not better than she was. They were simply different. They had different kinds of power and different kinds of proximity to evil. Their hatred reveals more about them than it reveals about her. And that is the bitter truth inside Hitler’s inner circle. Everyone was implicated. Everyone was compromised.
Everyone found ways to avoid looking directly at what they were part of. The generals blamed Ava Braun for their lack of influence. Ava Brar retreated into dreams of domesticity and romance. And Hitler sat at the center of it all, insulated from reality by both, making decisions that would cost millions of lives.
While his generals seethed and his mistress smiled, the story ends where all stories end in the silence that follows the final act. The bunker is quiet now. The generals are gone. Ava Brown is gone. Hitler is gone. What remains is the record of what happened and the endless task of trying to understand it. We study these people not because they deserve our attention, but because understanding them helps us understand ourselves, helps us recognize the patterns of power and resentment and denial that can emerge in any society under any conditions. Whenever human
beings gather and struggle for influence and control, that is the true lesson of this bitter truth. It is not really about Ava Brawn at all. It is about us, about the ways we seek power and the ways we resent those who have it, about the excuses we make and the scapegoats we find when our plans go wrong.
The generals of the Third Reich were not unique. They were just one example of a pattern that continues to this day. And recognizing that pattern in them and in ourselves is the beginning of wisdom. Your support helps us continue the deep research behind every episode. Buy us a coffee and fuel the next documentary.
Link is in the description. If this story has made you think differently about history, about power, or about the strange ways that personal relationships shape great events, then please consider subscribing to this channel. We tell the stories that don’t get told in textbooks. the human dramas behind the grand narratives, the bitter truths that make history come alive.
Hit the subscribe button, turn on [clears throat] notifications, and join us for the next chapter in the endless story of how we became who we are.
