The Unspeakable Things Women Endured in Comanche Captivity

.
.

The Captivity of Rachel Plamer: A Story of Survival and Resilience

In the early morning hours of May 19, 1836, a horrific scene unfolded at Fort Parker in Texas. A 17-year-old girl, Rachel Plamer, watched in terror as her father-in-law was struck down by a war club. Her mother-in-law lay bleeding in the dirt, and before Rachel could scream, warriors seized her, throwing her onto a horse. Six months pregnant and terrified, Rachel was about to endure a nightmare that would last for 21 months, a nightmare she would later struggle to recount even in the safety of her father’s home.

Rachel Plamer was one of thousands of women captured during this tumultuous period in American history. Throughout the 1800s, native tribes across the American Southwest raided frontier settlements, capturing women and children. Some were ransomed back to their families, some escaped, and many simply vanished without a trace. Those who returned carried stories of unimaginable suffering, stories that haunted them for the rest of their lives.

The Pattern of Raids

The raids typically followed a brutal pattern. Warriors attacked at dawn or dusk, exploiting the vulnerability of isolated homesteads. The men of the household were killed first, often within minutes, leaving women and children at the mercy of their captors. Women of childbearing age were the most valuable, as they could work, be traded, or become wives. Young girls were prized for similar reasons, while the elderly and infants were often killed immediately.

Rachel was thrust into this grim reality. After watching her family slaughtered, she was taken by the warriors, forced into a life of servitude. Her experience was not unique; it mirrored the fate of many women who found themselves in similar circumstances.

The Gruesome Reality of Captivity

Once captured, the women faced a harsh new existence. They were not treated as guests or prisoners; they were viewed as property. From the very first day, they were put to work, often before their wounds had healed. Rachel described her early months among the warriors as a time of constant labor, where she was beaten for failing to meet the demands placed upon her. The beatings were frequent and brutal, administered for any perceived weakness or failure to comply.

Another young girl, Olive Oatman, experienced a similarly harrowing fate. Captured at the age of 14, she watched her family brutally murdered before being dragged into the desert. Olive described walking barefoot through the wilderness, her feet torn and bleeding, driven forward by the fear of death. She and her sister were subjected to relentless labor, forced to work until they were on the brink of collapse.

Rachel’s narrative echoed this sentiment. She wrote about being constantly at work from dawn until late at night, enduring beatings for the slightest misstep. Her life became a cycle of dread and suffering, marked by cruelty that seemed to have no end.

The Psychological Toll

The psychological toll of captivity was often worse than the physical abuse. Many captives were subjected to rituals designed to break their spirits. One such ritual was known as “running the gauntlet,” where captives were forced to run between two rows of warriors armed with clubs and sticks. Each warrior struck them as they passed, a brutal initiation that served to demonstrate their new status as property.

Rachel Plamer’s experience included this ritual, and she learned quickly that showing pain only invited more violence. She adapted to survive, refusing to cry out, and instead, channeling her suffering into a determination to endure. Others, like Matilda Lockhart, were not as fortunate. Captured at just 13 years old, Matilda endured horrific abuse at the hands of her captors, who found amusement in her suffering. The scars of her experiences would haunt her for the rest of her life.

Stories of Survival

Despite the horrors, some women managed to survive and even find ways to endure their captivity. Rachel Plamer eventually found a semblance of strength and resilience, learning to navigate her new reality. She documented her experiences in a memoir, one of the first captivity narratives published, although she struggled to fully articulate the depths of her suffering.

Olive Oatman, after years of captivity, was finally ransomed back to her family. However, she returned a changed person, marked by the experiences she could never fully escape. The tattoos on her face served as a permanent reminder of her time among the Mojave tribe, a symbol of her captivity and transformation.

The Cost of Freedom

The cost of freedom was often steep. Many captives returned to their families only to find themselves unable to reintegrate into their former lives. The trauma they endured left deep scars, and they struggled to reconcile their past with the present. Rachel’s story ended tragically; after her release, she became pregnant again but died shortly after giving birth, her body simply unable to withstand the toll of her experiences.

The stories of these women—Rachel, Olive, and Matilda—reveal the brutal realities of frontier captivity. They were not just victims; they were survivors, witnesses to a dark chapter in American history. Their narratives serve as a reminder of the resilience of the human spirit in the face of unimaginable suffering.

Conclusion

The frontier was not merely a place of adventure; it was a landscape marked by violence, trauma, and survival. The women who endured captivity carried their stories with them, stories that revealed the complexities of human experience during a time of upheaval. They faced horrors that many could not fathom, yet they emerged with a strength that defied their circumstances.

Their accounts matter. They force us to confront the truth about our history—one that is often sanitized or forgotten. By remembering their stories, we honor their resilience and ensure that the lessons of the past are not lost to time. In a world that often chooses to look away, the narratives of Rachel Plamer, Olive Oatman, and Matilda Lockhart remind us of the importance of facing our history with honesty and compassion.